Preview: 2nd Gen offers ‘Proof’ in newest play
Buffalo Theater: Little theater company carving out a place in the District
By Mike Desmond
Every theater is a little different from the theater next door, clearly apparent in Buffalo’s Theatre District, with four theaters cheek to jowl and a giant rehearsal hall upstairs, all on one side of Main Street.
Shea’s Buffalo is primarily a stage to present traveling Broadway shows while Shea’s 710 is home for MusicalFare and some occasional other companies.
In the middle is Shea’s Smith Theatre, housing Second Generation Theatre and O’Connell & Company.
The Smith and 710 flank the Alleyway Theatre.
2nd Gen will be producing “Mean Girls” later this season in Shea’s 710.
But much sooner in the Smith, Second Generation is opening “Proof” Thursday night, working into the holiday season, skipping Turkey Day.
Artistic Director Kelly Copps praised the four-person show in an email interview, saying “‘Proof’ is one of the best shows of the last 25 years. It holds up against the test of time as the characters are so rich and layered; it’s also one of those shows that’s best viewed the first time so you can unravel the plot in real time.”
It had a Kavinoky Theatre production in 2018.
The Pulitzer Prize-winning David Auburn script revolves around a dead man, the dead professor of math who has left things behind, the troubled daughter who took care of father Robert in his later years, a former student and 103 notebooks.
In publicity for the show, Second Gen Executive Director Kristin Bentley said the show ties into the company’s role as a female-founded and female-led company: “It’s a play about math that really isn’t about math — it centers around a brilliant woman that no one is taking seriously. It’s a strikingly relevant conversation. The play also deals with mental illness and being in the position of caregiver in a nuanced, but relatable way.”
That’s why 2nd Gen is pairing up with the Junior League of Buffalo for an event after the performance Friday night, called “Every Woman, All Things,” discussing the JLB initiative of that name, using the play to talk about pressure on women to do it all.

Copps said, “When 2nd Gen began in 2013, we didn’t really think about being female-founded. We just happened to be all females. It wasn’t intentional. It also wasn’t common. Now, looking around Buffalo theaters, there are so many women running the show. This is a great thing. We’ve found that being female-founded and led is important to a lot of young people working with us and for us. We’re incredibly proud of it, and there’s nothing more wonderful than showing young woman that ‘yes, you can absolutely do this.’”
After all, Keelie Sheridan was artistic director right across the street from the Shea’s Smith at the Irish Classical Theatre.
Copps, Bentley and Arin Lee Dandes, actor and 2nd Gen board member, founded the company and kept it going through the COVID pandemic, which put several local theater companies out of business.
Copps says it has been hard, at times: “During COVID, not having our own space and being small and flexible is truly what kept us afloat. We were lucky in that way. On any given day, Kristin and I weigh the costs of having our own space versus renting. There are so many pros and cons to both sides, but we’re happy to be in the heart of Downtown in the Smith.”
Copps says the configuration of the Smith can be an issue,
“2nd Gen has enjoyed several seasons of reconfiguring the Smith for each show but this year, with assigned seating, we’re keeping it consistent all year. The size and configuration of the Smith definitely affects our choices, although it’s fair to say we have certainly stretched the limits of the space with some 17-person casts. We’re lucky enough to be able to flex up to 710 once a year for shows like ‘Mamma Mia’ and ‘Mean Girls’ that need more space.”
Copps continued, “Like any theater, we have some shows which knock it out of the park and some that underperform. We have an audience that trusts us to give them excellent show. We treat our season as a variety pack — something you know, something you don’t and something that’ll really make you think. It’s been working for us so far, even in a post-COVID landscape where patrons are overwhelmingly sticking to big musicals and titles they know. We’re not interested in giving up those unknown weird little shows — we love them and our audiences do too.”
There was that season-opening “Batboy: The Musical.”
THE CAST OF ‘PROOF’:




One thing theater companies watch is the local talent pool, which has shifted considerably in the wake of the pandemic; many companies staffing shows up to a year in advance to fill certain specific roles.
“The Buffalo talent pool is extraordinary for a city of our size. 2nd Gen loves casting shows that have new faces as well as tenured talent and this is no exception,” Copps said. “Matt Witten was offered the role of Robert shortly after the show was selected. When he agreed, Kristin Bentley, our director, built the cast around him. We held an audition, and Lauren, Anna and Steven were the folks that stood out. Lauren are Steven are both new to 2nd Gen, which is exciting, but they are a part of the Buffalo theatre community.”
That’s Lauren Farrow, Anna Krempholtz and Steven Maiseka.
Witten is a well-known performer on local stages and Krempholtz was slated to be in “Three Tall Women,” the Edward Albee play cancelled a week before opening by Second Generation back in 2020 because of the COVID epidemic.
They will all be on stage to look at a man’s legacy, good or bad.
For more info, go to https://secondgenerationtheatre.com.
