Review: Punch Brothers play unsung heroes
Buffalo Music: Band goes way beyond bluegrass in CFA show
By Dale Anderson
(Photo by Dale Anderson)
The Punch Brothers aren’t entirely brothers these days. There’s a sister — Boston-based bluegrass fiddler Brittany Haas. She replaced founding member Gabe Witcher in 2023.
The punch, however, is just as powerful as ever. The five of them packed plenty of it into nearly two hours Sunday evening in the Mainstage concert hall at the University at Buffalo Performing Arts Center in Amherst.
Ostensibly a bluegrass band — there’s the traditional lineup of banjo, guitar, mandolin, fiddle and standup bass — they go way above and beyond mountain music. Stephen Holden of the New York Times has described it as “American country-classical chamber music.” I’d love to hear the Buffalo Chamber Players do some Punch Brothers.
Their dynamics are awe-inspiring. They go from near silence to a full orchestral roar and back down again in an instant. Furiously percussive, they’re prone to odd sound effects. On top of that, there’s all their individual prowess as soloists.
It’s no wonder, then, that they’ve forsaken vocals entirely on their latest album, “The Unsung Adventures of Punch Brothers.” It’s all instrumental numbers. At one point in the show, banjo player Noam Pikelny observed — at length, with deliberate irony — that there are just too many words around us.
Nevertheless, the mist-shrouded set began with mandolinist Chris Thile singing a verse of Gordon Lightfoot’s “The Wreck of the Edward Fitzgerald” a cappella before all the instruments fired up. And when they came back for an encore, they did the entire song.
Setlist.fm doesn’t have what they played at UB, at least not yet. The rundown from Saturday night in the State Theater in Ithaca lists around half of the songs from the new album, but not “Descend, O Diamondback,” which spotlighted bassist Paul Kowert. And not “Edmund Fitzgerald.”
