Review: The ‘Proof’ is in the timing this time out
Buffalo Theater: Auburn play at 2nd Gen takes serious look at issues that ‘Sister’ spoofs
By Lona LaChiusa
(Image above, L-R: Matt Witten and Lauren Farrow in “Proof”)
This week Saturday Night Live dropped a sketch called “Sister,” inserting it into the national conversation about caring for aging parents and skewering how that responsibility often falls to daughters at the expense of their own lives. It is kismet that Second Generation Theatre is currently running David Auburn’s Pulitzer Prize and Tony award winning Proof, a brilliant play that tackles this exact dynamic head-on.
Set on the back porch of a house in Chicago’s Hyde Park neighborhood, Catherine, now 25, struggles with the recent passing of her father, a genius mathematician and college professor whose gradual decline has consumed Catherine’s college years. She lovingly sacrifices her own career in order to care for Robert, and is also terrified that her own mathematical prowess might come at the cost of the severe mental illness that ravaged her father’s mind. The play moves from present to past, and the juxtaposition of a certain scene in Act 2 amplifies the heartbreaking realities Catherine has faced.
Having had the privilege of seeing the original Broadway cast, notably starring Mary-Louise Parker, I’ve been a big fan of the play for a long time. With a cast of four and a simple set, as well as relatable family conflicts, Proof has become a staple of regional theatres across the country. So it is always a relevant, well-crafted play worth seeing.
2nd Gen’s Proof is a decent production of the play. The play, as well as the production, are anchored in Catherine, played here effectively by Lauren Farrow. Farrow is authentic and believable.. She handles Catherine’s deflective sarcasm and intellectual confidence well, but still manages to find her deep vulnerabilities. Occasionally Farrow isn’t given enough of the physical space to work with, sometimes limited in the way Catherine inhabits the porch in her overwhelming grief and fatigue.
There are moments that build to surprising twists in the play and they really need to land hard. Catherine’s credibility needs to be in question and the way the other characters push back needs to be carefully constructed. Sometimes the energy and intention in this production dissipated a bit, leaving moments where characters seemed a little too performative, showing an unevenness in vocal control or line delivery when building to a climactic moment.
Yet Steven Maiseke as Hal, Matt Witten as Robert and Anna Krempholtz as Claire all have strong moments. Krempholtz and Farrow do have a shared sisterly chemistry at play, especially in Act 2. Claire could easily become a caricature, but Krempholtz conveys genuine concern, reasonable thinking and good intentions for her sister’s well-being. Witten seems to be choosing to play a little more of the diminished illness than the commanding and charismatic presence he is in Catherine’s life. Maiseke brings Hal’s frenetic energy in contrast to Catherine’s stillness, but it is crucial for the audience to question how much of him is earnestly in her corner and how much of him is a calculated opportunist.
Shea’s Smith Theatre brings an inescapable sense of both intimacy and confinement to the piece, and the design elements do enough to establish the world of the play without quite elevating it. The porch and yard could feel more neglected and lived-in, and stronger shifts in lighting and sound would help clarify both the changing seasons and the “nerds gone wild” house party happening just inside. By contrast, the original Broadway staging made expressive use of every inch of the porch and yard, even using the metallic click of a swinging screen door to punctuate dramatic beats.
Directed by 2nd Gen Executive Director Kristin Bentley, “Proof” is a heartfelt evening of theatre, even if it doesn’t quite deliver some of the play’s sharpest tension. “Proof” runs from now until Dec. 6 at Shea’s Smith Theatre.
