Review: Ujima’s ‘Where We Stand’ breaks new ground
12 mins read

Review: Ujima’s ‘Where We Stand’ breaks new ground

Buffalo Theater: Donnetta Lavinia Grays, Curtis Lovell and Gabriella McKinley invite us into a world where storytelling becomes an act of community

By Annette Daniels-Taylor
(Image above: Gabriella McKinley in “Where We Stand”)

In Where We Stand, playwright Donnetta Lavinia Grays uses perhaps the most basic and enduring method within theatre: storytelling. She creates a world, leads us in and asks for our participation. From the moment the play begins, we are invited to become part of the story.

Directed by Curtis Lovell, artistic director of Ujima Theatre Company, and starring company member Gabriella McKinley, Where We Stand is an extraordinary piece of theater. A one-woman show, running approximately 90 minutes including an intermission, and McKinley plays every character. Every single one. With remarkable clarity, she establishes the physicality, voice, personality and presence of each character, making it easy for us to distinguish one from another. This was an impressive demonstration of craft, imagination and fearless command of the stage.

When Lovell first read Grays’s script, they recognized what a wonderful vehicle it would be for McKinley. That instinct was right; it’s also a testament of how Ujima sees the talent within its own company and the opportunities it creates for its artists to stretch, develop and demonstrate the full range of their abilities.

The program describes Where We Stand as a morality play and a folktale. It’s also to me a contemporary fable, told through long, beautifully constructed poetic, lyrical prose. And while this isn’t a musical, music is an essential part of its theatrical language.

Before the play even begins, Lovell has already started preparing us for the experience.

RELATED: The pre-show playlist.

Sitting in the audience listening to the pre-show music, I became aware of the emotional landscape being established. I don’t remember every song, but I remember the feelings they evoked. I thought about grief, community, change, activism and movements for social justice. I recognized the voices of Black women singer-songwriters, including Rhiannon Giddens, Joan Armatrading, Tracy Chapman and Valerie June.

The music was doing precisely what good pre-show music does: preparing us for what we will experience. It established an emotional and cultural landscape becoming increasingly meaningful as the story unfolded.

The production opens with McKinley entering the stage singing. The theater is dark, and as the lights come up, she begins inviting us to sing along. She doesn’t give instruction, she sings, gives us the lyrics and waits for us to catch on.

The audience represents the residents of this fictional town and our participation is part of the experience.

Lovell makes another interesting choice with the music. Using a beat machine, an instrument they have mastered and taught McKinley to use for the performance, they create an additional layer of storytelling. The beats, rhythms and sounds become part of the world of the play. They work alongside the language, adding texture and atmosphere to the already lyrical quality of Grays’ writing.

Gabriella McKinley

The music isn’t simply there to accompany the performance. It gives McKinley another way to build the world around us, to expand our imagination and to take us further into the journey she is asking us to share.

What Grays has written, Lovell has thoughtfully shaped into a theatrical experience that feels both intimate and expansive. Together, with McKinley at its center, they create a warm and inviting circle for us, the audience, to inhabit.

We are not simply watching this fictional community from the outside. We are living in it together, in concert and in community. The voices, the story, the sounds and the words are familiar and welcoming, even as the questions they raise are complicated and sometimes uncomfortable.

There is something wonderfully generous about that invitation. The production makes room for us. It gives us a place within the story and reminds us that storytelling has always been one of the ways we gather, recognize ourselves and understand one another.

At the heart of Where We Stand is a question about the consequence of receiving your heart’s desire and the inevitable reading of a contract’s fine print. At the end of the play, the audience is asked to make a decision about the protagonist. Do we punish them, or do we absolve them?

I found myself considering the options we were given. Our protagonist is naive and not sophisticated in the ways of the world. They live alone, have been ostracized and overlooked by society, while living with a  debilitating physical condition. There is a compassion beginning to fill up within us for them in the first act. 

By act two when we are faced with the decision we consider: did they really understand what they were getting into? Were they smart enough to know any better? Were they chosen because they were simple? Were they singled out as a perfect patsy? How do we determine responsibility when the circumstances surrounding a decision are complicated?

And perhaps the more difficult question: Who are we to decide? And would we have done the same thing?

I was touched by the emotional weight of being asked to make that choice as a member of the community. We judge people every day. We make decisions about their actions, their intentions and whether they deserve forgiveness or empathy. But how often do we stop to consider the circumstances that brought them to that moment?

Grays gives us an opportunity to examine those questions, not from a distance, but as participants. We are implicated in the story because we are asked to be the jury. Grays doesn’t just ask us to consider what forgiveness means, she also asks us what accountability looks like, and what it means to take responsibility for the things we do, even when we may not fully understand their consequences.

In Lovell’s director’s notes, they write:

“This show was a timely project for me. I feel as though I am at a point in my work as a creative, that I have a better understanding of consequence.”

They go on to reflect on the decisions we make when we say yes or no, and the responsibilities that follow. Whether positive or negative, Lovell writes, “there are things you must answer to and for.”

They describe Where We Stand as “a morality play hidden in prose and disguised in simplicity.”

And it is that disguise of simplicity that makes the production so effective.

McKinley’s performance is a tour de force. The range of her work is remarkable.

There is an extraordinary amount of stamina, discipline and, most importantly, love for one’s craft required to deliver a performance of this magnitude. McKinley dances, moves, sings, shifts characters, and navigates the physical and emotional demands of the story with remarkable precision. Her athleticism is not limited to her body. It is also vocal and intellectual. The control, concentration, imagination and sheer energy required to sustain this performance are outstanding.

And what makes her performance so special is the generosity with which she shares it. Gabriella McKinley takes our hands and escorts us into this all-too-real fictional world. She invites us to travel with her, to meet its characters, to inhabit its community and ultimately to become part of its story.

She will make you smile, laugh, feel and, more importantly, she will move you.

This is a remarkable gift from an actor who clearly understands not only the demands of her craft but the responsibility and joy of sharing it with an audience.

During intermission, I overheard a student from Buffalo Seminary say, “Oh my God, do you know how talented you have to be to be able to do what she just did?” Her cohorts were in complete agreement, and so was I.

There is something wonderful about hearing young people respond to a performance with that kind of genuine astonishment. They understood that they were watching an artist doing something extraordinary. And I thought that was a beautiful testament to McKinley’s work.

Gabriella McKinley

I want to recognize Ujima’s resident lighting designer, Kyra Jade Bogden. Her lighting design is exquisite, and her sound work contributes significantly to the atmosphere and emotional texture of the production. The technical elements are thoughtfully integrated into the storytelling, allowing the performance, the language and the music to work together beautifully.

I also want to acknowledge what Ujima Theatre Company is doing with its programming. The company isn’t simply giving Buffalo audiences more of the standard theatrical fare. It is making room for experimental, poetic and new work. They’re presenting stories and theatrical experiences that we may not have encountered before, and work that, quite frankly, Buffalo isn’t seeing enough of.

And that’s good. Actually, it’s great. And it’s important.

We need theater that challenges us. We need work that asks audiences questions about their lives, how they think, how they feel and how they understand the world around them. We need productions that allow us to leave the theater still thinking, still questioning and still talking about what we have experienced.

Because that’s how change happens. It happens within our lives, our relationships, our communities and the world we share.

Where We Stand is ultimately about community: how we make it, how we evolve within it and how we become one. The audience’s participation is not simply an entertaining theatrical device, it is central to the experience. We are asked to become part of a community, to consider the consequences of someone’s actions and to decide what we believe that person deserves.

And when the play ends, those questions don’t necessarily end with it.

This is what theater can do. It can take something as fundamental as storytelling; put us in a room together and remind us that we are connected to one another in ways we may not always recognize.

Where We Stand runs Nov. 21, 22 and Dec. 3–6 at Ujima Theatre Company. Admission to Ujima’s productions during the remainder of the season are Pay What You Can at the box office. Seating for this production is limited, so if you like to show up close to curtain you may want to buy a full price ticket online that guarantees a seat.

Bring your children. Bring your students. Bring your mother, your father, your cousins, your partners and your friends. See this production together. Then talk about it. Talk about the questions it raises, because they are questions that are affecting us right now.

As Curtis Lovell reminds us, whether our choices are positive or negative, there are things we must answer to and for.

Where We Stand may change the way you think about storytelling. It may change the way you think about theater. And it just might change the way you understand consequence, forgiveness and your responsibility to the community around you.

This is a beautiful show. A magical show.

Whatever you do, don’t miss it.

Annette Daniels-Taylor is a playwright, actor, director and media artist living in Buffalo, New York. Annette teaches at Buffalo State University.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *